Shouting down Margaret Wente in Halifax

Nov 1, 2008

Shouting down Margaret Wente in Halifax

This post has not been approved by Media Co-op editors!

The name Margaret Wente scarcely needs an introduction to Dominion readers. Please refer to the main Dominion paper site at http://dominionpaper.ca for details of her most recent academically veiled example racism.

Wente was the keynote speaker at the Joseph Howe Symposium organized by the University of King's College School of Journalism and Calgary's Sheldon Chumir Foundation for Ethics in Leadership. This year's event, which took place in Halifax on November 1st, was "The Media's Right to Offend: Exploring Legal and Ethical Limits on Free Speech".

Before Wente actually took the podium, there was an introduction by a moderator. He did mention the Facebook group calling on the Globe and Mail to have her fired; he alluded to the controversial portrayal of native peoples she made; he got into details of how her views have generally been considered offensive over the years; he quoted angry respondents to Wente's work. More importantly though, he also gave her accolades and did not detail why, specifically, Wente was under such pressure to be fired. The appearance he created was that some people were upset at her opinions because she is a provocative writer who is not afraid to say things that may offend some people, and walks the fine line between fair comment and hate/discriminatory/offensive speech.

My mind was made up that I could not let her go on without interjecting a preamble to add some more substance to the controversy over her now infamous article, "What Dick Pound said was really dumb -- and also true" (Oct. 24, 2008). I was not going to wait for the question period to give her racist views an air of legitimacy.

I was glad that I have done some theatre training in the last year that granted me the ability to project my voice to the whole auditorium.

I loudly informed everyone that I was concerned about Margaret Wente speaking without first providing some more context about the justification that people had for calling on the Globe and Mail to fire her.

The audience needed to be made aware that her article contained information that is completely false, upon which she based her justification for assimilation of native peoples' i.e. cultural genocide. Particularly, I was referring to her comments: "Claims about aboriginal contributions to civilization are also vastly overstated. Did the Iroquois Confederacy really influence the Declaration of Independence? Sorry, no. Do native medicinal herbs play an important role in modern drugs? No."

The room was actually surprisingly good for yelling, very little echo.

I explained to the audience that if they were to read Ronald Wright's "Stolen Continents" (1992), they would be informed that writers of the U.S. Constitution / Declaration of Independence were in fact heavily influenced by the Iroquois Confederacy. Both Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin made comments to this effect. Benjamin Franklin was so impressed by the Iroquois Confederacy that he championed it as a model to unite the new colonies and urged that each colony become a state with control over internal affairs and with a federal council responsible for external matters. This became the basis of the Articles of Confederation. "Stolen Continents" contains quotes from Benjamin Franklin detailing the very direct influence. For the record, Wright's book also has comments from a native elder explaining that although the U.S Constitution was influenced by the Iroquois Confederacy, originally, U.S. Administrators didn't exactly get the basic ideas right along the way, to say the least.

As for Wente's denial that native medicines had any effect on the development of modern medicines, she completely whitewashes an entire history of native peoples providing medical care to Europeans. Who was it that actually cured Europeans of scurvy again? I emphatically stated this point. The historical note is well known, but she is still attempting to (white) paint the picture that the "modern world" arose without any help from native peoples along the way.

Further, I made sure to loudly pronounce Wente as a RACIST, who for years has been using her column in the Globe and Mail to bash Muslims since September 11th. I wanted to ensure that people at least could hear one frustrated person detailing how her recent controversial column was not an isolated incident.

Actually, I barely got to say most of what I refer to above. I scarcely mentioned the word "Iroquois" before some people began booing. This kept going on for the few minutes that I was talking. When I started speaking about the Wente's Islam bashing, many people started clapping as one or more people told me to shut up. I commented that it was an interesting reaction from a room that was almost entirely white (Over 150 people in attendance and no more than five people of colour, including myself). I didn't have the chance to let people know that Wente is actually a champion for white supremicists because she writes what they want to hear. Do a search for "Margaret Wente" and "white pride" and see what you find.