The Media Co-op

Local Independent News

More independent news:
Do you want free independent news delivered weekly? sign up now
Can you support independent journalists with $5? donate today!

This Was Our Playground

In which we condemn 45 years of unabated dumping at Boat Harbour.

by Miles Howe

Maurina Beadle Motions Towards the Tail-End of the Pictou Mill's Effluent-Dumping Pipe. Be Thankful Photos Can't Transmit Smell.
Maurina Beadle Motions Towards the Tail-End of the Pictou Mill's Effluent-Dumping Pipe. Be Thankful Photos Can't Transmit Smell.

We are looking at a rushing torrent of bubbling, dark brown liquid. It gushes out of the mouth of a 2.5 metre pipe. The flow expels hundreds of litres of effluent waste per second. Foul foam, crust, and spray, lines the banks of a canal that contains the noxious outflow.

The smell from the outflow is overwhelming; an unidentifiable potpourri of chemical soup. This is Boat Harbour, Nova Scotia. The Backwater. We are standing at the tail-end of a pipe that has, for over 40 years, been dumping effluent waste from the Abercrombie Point Pulp and Paper Mill into what was once a natural tidal estuary.

“This was our playground,” says my companion, Maurina Beadle, from Pictou Landing First Nation. Hobbled by a stroke, but still able to clamber around a chain-link fence should the need arise, Beadle has echoed this phrase all day. From the desolation of Moodey's Cove, where a brown tide now washes where swimmers once came to frolic, and shellfish were harvested by the bucket; to the brave little town of Pictou, population 5,000, its own harbour now poisoned and devoid of fish; to the bleakest black of Boat Harbour itself; all of this was a Mig'maw playground for thousands upon thousands of years. Now, the beaches are lined with strange warnings, that sinkholes may appear at any time, and Boat Harbour is decimated.

Something has gone horribly wrong here, and the foul smell that hangs over the entire area is simply the most obvious of indicators. This is a place, and a people, made sick by a mill; sanctioned, subsidized, and approved of, by all levels of government.

In the early 1960s, the Pictou Landing Indian Band was swindled out of Boat Harbour. Representatives of the Band were brought to an in-operational, and hence pristine, effluent treatment site in Saint John, New Brunswick. They were told they could expect the same quality of water at Boat Harbour. And things have never been the same since then.

In July of 1993, after 7 years of legal wrangling, the federal government awarded the Pictou Landing Indian Band $35 million to settle a lawsuit brought before the Crown. The lawsuit stemmed from the federal government's failure to protect the band from the pollution caused by Boat Harbour.

In 2008, after an extended history of broken promises, backroom dealings, and indemnity agreements signed between the provincial government and the mill, the provincial Conservative government at the time promised to shut down the treatment facility at Boat Harbour. In September of 2010, after effluent-dumping-as-usual continued, the Pictou Landing Indian Band decided to sue the province, as well as current and past owners of the mill, for a variety of charges, mostly related to loss of environmental enjoyment and health-related issues.

It is now 2011, and the effluent continues to flow. As we have reported, a draft “Capacity Building Agreement”, worth $3 million if the band ices its lawsuit for the next 24 months, is now on the table. It would be unfortunate if this offer were accepted, seeing that the poisoned waters of Boat Harbour, the often-leaking effluent-dumping pipe, and the noxious fumes from the mill, do not just affect the Mig'maw of Pictou Landing.

“Pictou is another Lunenberg. Or a Bridgewater. Or any of those nice towns on the South Shore. This fits in that group. But with that thing over there?” says Pictou town councillor Raymond Gregory, motioning to the smoke-belching mill that ruins an otherwise picturesque fall day. “We're never going to realize the full potential of what we have here in Pictou. People have to live with that for some miserable bastard to drive a Mercedes and live in the big castle on the hill. That’s the price people have to pay around here. It’ll make you sick! But even over here at the courthouse, you can’t get the high end people [to pay attention]. The judges, you’d think they’d get in on this, but everybody’s tied in, making a nice, neat, little nest.”

We have also reported that health issues abound in Pictou County. Logic suggests that elevated rates of cancer and respiratory disease amongst its citizens might prompt some action from the provincial government. But, according to Ron Kelly, spokesperson for the Pictou County Watershed Coalition, the only action the current Dexter government is good for is a 'run-around'. Kelly's group wants an epidemiological study done of the community. An epidemiological study would be the first step in identifying the root causes of Pictou County's various health problems. Unfortunately, all Kelly's gotten so far is a bureaucratic-sized head-ache.

“We petitioned to the Minister of the Environment, and he...sidestepped the issue and said ‘I can't deal with that because it's a health issue.’” says Kelly. “He forwarded our letter to Maureen McDonald, the Minister of Health...and she said ‘You should get in touch with your local health authority.’ So we got in touch with the local health authority and went through a series of meetings which ended up being very frustrating. We want to move the issue forward. The local health authority brought in people from around the province to tell us why they couldn't do that.”

Indeed, this reporter was refused commentary by Minister McDonald's office, who then told to me contact the Ministry of Health, who then told me to contact the Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure Renewal (no reason was given as to why), who then told me to contact the Ministry of Indian Affairs, where the trail runs cold with the Director of Consultation, Alvaro Loyola. Loyola refused comment on nearly every question, except that his department is “looking at possibilities.” All we have been able to ascertain, through no assistance from government sources, is that the only possibility being looked at is a $3 million pay-off.

Given the breadth and scope of this run-around, whose trail runs cold in classic bureaucratic rhetoric, it is difficult to determine which provincial department, if any, is actually managing the Boat Harbour file. There is certainly no solution on the table for cleaning Boat Harbour, or diverting the effluent from the mill to another suitable location. Unfortunately, there is the constantly-pondered notion of building an effluent-dumping pipe directly into the Northumberland Strait, but seeing as how Pictou Harbour water has promptly given shellfish Leukaemia in lab tests, this doesn't seem like much of a good idea for Nova Scotia's fishing industry.

And while the local health authority says it’s not possible, an epidemiological health study is indeed doable. In 2009, Inka Milewski of the Conservation Council of New Brunswick undertook a epidemiological analysis of her province, and was able to determine cancer levels right down to the community level. Milewski found that occupational exposure to carcinogens was the likely cause of elevated cancer rates in Saint John, and that the 'old standby' excuse of cigarette smoking didn't apply, as rates of smoking in Saint John are below the provincial average. Cancer-related groups applauded the quality of the study.

The Abercrombie mill, for its massive pollution, has received tens of millions of dollars in bail-outs, loans, more loans, and grants, from all levels of government. None of this $100 million+ has ever been earmarked to deal with the issue of Boat Harbour.

And yet, Northern Pulp, currently the mill's owners, seem to be hopping onto the green-washing wagon. This despite the fact that they continue to pollute Boat Harbour, and despite the fact that their effluent-dumping pipe is a consistent leaker.  They've even begun writing their own environmentally-conscious, so-called, 'news'.

In a May of 2010 press release, Northern Pulp notes that it has “reaffirmed its commitment to environmental stewardship” and has signed an agreement with the Pictou Harbour Environment Protection Project. Which sounds nice, until you realize that the president of the PHEPP, Jack Kyte, was former Public Affairs manager for Northern Pulp, and Robert Christie, Executive Director of the PHEPP, who now considers himself an environmentalist, was a former bigwig for Canso Chemicals, and has been tight with mill bosses for decades.

“That's the mill mafia.” says councillor Gregory. “That's the fox watching the chicken coop.”

Speaking of mafia, it bears noting that the Northern Pulp mill has in fact been sold to Paper Excellence. Paper Excellence, as we reported, is a shell company of Indonesian conglomerate Asia Pulp and Paper, which is itself the tree-cutting arm of Sinar Mas, a company with well-known ties to former Indonesian dictator Suharto. Greenpeace has launched a successful campaign against Asia Pulp and Paper products, due to its polluting ways, and large North American box stores now refuse to carry its products. Apparently, perhaps for fear of name-brand recognition, Paper Excellence is not changing the name of the Pictou mill. But take note, the Northern Pulp mill is now an Asia Pulp and Paper acquisition, and is now in cahoots with manufacturing a product that is banned by many chain stores.

As for Maurina Beadle, herself involved in a battle with the government for childcare, after her stroke she spent weeks learning to walk again. Her recovery room had a horrible view of the Abercrombie mill. Now 54, having lived with the stench, and sight, and pollution, of the mill for all of her adult life, she maintains her resolve to see it shut.

“Far too many tears have cried over this.” says Beadle. “And far too many years have gone by. You're looking at the younger generation and the babies that are coming up. You don't want them to grow up the same way. You don't want to see them hurt in any way, any more than we were hurt when we were growing up with the paper mill. It doesn't matter which way you look at it, it was a hardship all around. And yes, it would be nice to see it close down, totally. Once and for all.”


Socialize:
Want more grassroots coverage?
Join the Media Co-op today.
Topics: Environment

Creative Commons license icon Creative Commons license icon

About the poster

Trusted by 6 other users.
Has posted 494 times.
View Miles Howe's profile »

Recent Posts:


Miles Howe (Miles Howe)
Halifax Nov Scotia
Member since October 2010

About:


1627 words

Comments

just like the tar ponds, bye

This remindes me of when I was a kid and my mother brought me to visit the homes on Frederick Street in Sydney--that's the street directly adjacent to the tar ponds--to see for ourselves the orange ooze coming through the basements of those houses. It had been tested by the residents, and it was largely was arsenic. The provincial department of health denied that it was arsenic, and maintained that there were no adverse health effects from the ooze, and that there were certainly no adverse health effects from living beside the tar ponds. Some group at the time did a study of cancer rates in Nova Scotia, by region and community. It was amazing to see how Nova Scotia's rates of cancer, the highest in the country, were brought down to the national average once Cape Breton's rates were removed. And how Cape Breton's dropped to the national average once Sydney's cancer numbers were taken out. And how Sydney's dropped to very close to the national average once the neighbourhood around the tar ponds were removed.

This phenomenon is not going to change. We cannot depend on government to do what is right for us, to properly represent our interests. We have to make that change happen ourselves.

You're right. We've been

You're right. We've been fighting this for 40 years and have nothing but runarounds from all levels of our governments and from the civil servants who are supposed to be there for us. But the residents of Pictou Landing and the PL First Nations are a small population and easily ignored by the majority of Pictou County residents who THINK their own health isn't affected by the pollution --it probably is, but who knows for sure when no relevant health study will ever be done by a complicit government who actually OWNS the Boat Harbour facility? 

Few people know this, but in 1925 the federal government had plans to create a national park at Boat Harbour. That's how beautiful and wonderful it was. And could be again. Meanwhile, just google images of it today and you'll see what they did instead.

Thanks

Miles, we haven't met but I am now your biggest fan. Thanks so much for writing this! You have the essential facts and the whole sad story absolutely right. We live next to the Rez and hence only a few hundred metres from Boat Harbour. Our beautiful waterfront home (where I grew up) here at Moodie Cove is a death trap and what should be a paradise is often more like hell itself. Thanks for caring when all levels of government have demonstrated their indifference, and thanks for your clarity when misinformation and deceit are the order of the day.

Epidemiological Study is a must!

It's intersting/frustrating that all government levels seem to know who is responsible for taking the credit (through photo ops and conveniently timed press releases) when they give money to continuously 'save the mill' but then when it's time to deal with the ill effects of the reality of the mills operations...they all dissappear! 

There are numerous studies that show there are ill effects associated with this mills effluent and stack emissions.  From day one county Doctors pleaded with the government to be aware of these concerns but money always came first. 

One such Doctor was Dr. Dan Reid, Cheif of Staff of the former Pictou Hospital.  He voiced his concerns in the Nova Scotia Medical Journal, in 1989, when he was alarmed by the fact that Pictou County has the higest rates of cancer in Canada.  He was also even more concerned to note the large number of respiratory cases his hospital was seeing.

Dr. Reid also noted worry for the workers of the mill writing 'In 1989, Solet et al, described an increase in lung cancer in pulp and paper workers and indeed, an increase in all malignant neoplasms in workers with greater than thirty years employment'

Why would the government continue to turn a blind eye to this and so may other facts?

In the words of Dr. Dan Reid "Common sense and observation establishes that Pictou's atomsphere differs from other communities in Nova Scotia only by the fact it is in the immediate vicinity of the air emissions from the [then] Scott kraft pulp mill"

 

Also Interesting

I agree that an epidemiological study is a must.

Did you also notice that the Chronicle Herald stole the earlier story about the $3 million hush money, posted it as their own, and put a corporate media spin on it?

Yep, after Pal Bou, another HMC reporter, emailed Chronically Horrid editor Dan Leger, to alert him to the story, Leger went out, and through a reporter got a capacity building agreement of his own through his government connections.

The Horrid then put the spin on it that the Band had come looking for the money, which is an idea not found anywhere within the document. In a classic, "Let's make the natives look bad" move, the Horrid's article attempts to pit the Pictou Landing Band against non-Native Pictou Landing locals, who simply can't understand why the Natives would give up the lawsuit for cash, after they worked so hard to get it going. This plays into an already-existing split, as Natives have received past compensation for living next to a toxic mess, while non-Natives have not.

The Horrid's article came out two days after our own, and they don't even reference the fact that we have a second document that talks about the fact that the Band is out of money to continue to lawsuit. The Horrid considers the HMC too small to even note. They merely say "Sources say..."

I would urge all readers not to fall into the corporate media spin machine, and not to scapgoat the Pictou Landing First Nation to the detriment of the issue. The Band did not go looking for the $3 million, the issue is not settled, and internal consultation within the Band is ongoing. Now is not the time to gaze in wonder at the PLFN, as the Horrid would have us do, and wonder why they sold-out. There is no sell out. Only pollution on a massive scale, and a Band that may well have no more money left to continue the legal battle. The Horrid does not even mention that the only way the PLFN could get the provincial government to make good on their promises of shutting down Boat Harbour is by taking them to court. Shame! Cancel your subscriptions!

What we see is that corporate media and the government's position is business as usual. Do not bite the hook that is offered. The kind and benefactory government offers the PLFN $3 million because it notices it needs capacity building? Garbage. The second document notes that Indian and Nothern Affairs Canada is aware that the band is underfunded, and that the provincial money is contingent upon stopping the lawsuit for at least 2 years, which puts the issue of stopping Boat Harbour past the next election, which works handily for this government.

If the band is known to be underfunded, why not give them $3 million and shut down Boat Harbour? Why one and not the other? Why only give them $3 million provided they live next to a terrible dump? As though $3 million will take the smell away, or take the cancer victims back, or make the water clean again. Where is the lawyer who will take this case on?

People still subscribe to the Herald?

I thought everyone smartened up already and gave that shitbag newspaper the boot long ago.

I still remember the day that I phoned in to cancel my subscription after holding it for 4 months... that was the day there was a massive offensive in the early days of the Iraq war that got buried back to page 3 in favour of a full front page photo of some youth tobogganing down citadel hill.

What a ridiculous newspaper.  I wouldn't even wipe my ass with it.

Join the media co-op today
Things the Media Co-op does: Support
Things the Media Co-op does: Report
Things the Media Co-op does: Network
Things the Media Co-op does: Educate
Things the Media Co-op does: Discover
Things the Media Co-op does: Cooperate
Things the Media Co-op does: Build
Things the Media Co-op does: Amplify

User login


Google+
Subscribe to the Dominion $25/year

The Media Co-op's flagship publication features in-depth reporting, original art, and the best grassroots news from across Canada and beyond. Sign up now!